Truth Before Dishonor

I would rather be right than popular

Easter: The Most Holy Day Of The Year

Posted by John Hitchcock on 2012/04/08

Or is it?

Week of Passion…and Possible Divorce (God’s Perfect Timing) — Vip Ogola’s description of the week leading up to and including Easter/Passover Sunday. And I’d say that is a very apt description of all the events that took place from Palm Sunday to Easter Sunday a little over 2,000 years ago.

What I’m about to deliver today will sound familiar to many who read my articles, because I’ve said it before on Truth Before Dishonor and the now archive-only Common Sense Political Thought, both of which had threads with worthwhile comments, although at CSPT, you have to scan through mostly rubbish in the comment section.

Easter is important.
Air is desirable.
Water has value.

There are many who consider Easter the most important celebratory day of the year. I may be one of them but I am not entirely certain. Let me explain my predicament, using a Progressive tool: Values Clarification (which is actually values modification).

You are planning a journey to colonize the moon. In your plans, you have to decide what to take with you. There will be no other trips to your colony for a year. You have limited space, so you will have to do without a lot of things you would prefer to have in order to make your life on the moon survivable. List these items in order of importance:

Housing unit
Cold-weather clothing
Hot-weather clothing
Excavation tools
Compressed air
Lunar maps
Lunar compasses

So, what did you decide was most important for your trip? Air, perhaps? Without air, nobody will survive longer than a few short minutes. Without water, nobody will survive more than a few days. Without food, nobody will survive more than a few weeks. Without proper shelter or clothing, it is highly unlikely you could survive a week. So it’s quite possible that air is the most important on the list. Or is it?

If you will not gain anything for a year, what importance is the fraction-of-year survival without a certain item compared to the importance of the fraction-of-year survival without a different item? No matter how you order it, if you’re missing one for that duration, you’re still just as dead after the year is up.

So, what celebratory day is more important? Easter, Christmas or Good Friday? Without Easter, there would be no Resurrection and thus no redemption of sin. There could be no Resurrection without the Crucifixion celebrated on Good Friday (which I believe is the wrong day). That means the redemption of sin could not occur. Without the Birth, there could be no Crucifixion. Without the Virgin Conception, everything is moot. Remove any one of these four events and the other three events lose all their value. Remove Jesus’ 33 years of sin-free life and all four events lose all their value. And, as Vip Ogola reminded me, if Joseph had divorced his betrothed Mary as she was pregnant with Jesus as he had strongly considered before Providence spoke directly to him, again, all would be moot.

So, in the grand scheme of things, can any of the events truly be ordered as more important than the others?

As I said, my earlier article discussing this issue provided some worthwhile comments from the readers, and even a philosophical/logical discussion or two. On the TBD article, my MUD-geek friend Adara (pray for her as she’s still emotionally healing from the recent loss of her mother, whom she talks about in that 2010 thread), who is Catholic, said I gave her food for thought and was mulling over what I wrote. She also asked why I suggested Good Friday may be the wrong day. I explained my reasoning and invited Jeff, a non-Christian Liberal Jew (who I don’t know is practicing or not), to delve into the math of it and the Jewish nature of it, Which he did.

As I said, the CSPT thread is mostly unrelated garbage but Tyro visited to give me article-related grief and I believe left with a better understanding than he started with. If you want to follow that particular conversation,
Link 1
Link 2
Link 3
Link 4

7 Responses to “Easter: The Most Holy Day Of The Year”

  1. Foxfier said

    So, in the grand scheme of things, can any of the events truly be ordered as more important than the others?

    I’d say yes.

    I look at it from the POV that there are other things that could have been substituted in for some of them– but Easter is THE day of triumph. It includes the Incarnation, the Crucifixion AND is the rising from the dead. By requiring all the prior, it also includes the prior.

    To use the metaphor: is it more important to have water, air, food, or The Complete Moon Survival Kit?


  2. Yes, but within the metaphor, Easter is air, without which everyone dies exceedingly quickly. It’s not the whole shebang. Lot rose from the dead. Elijah and Enoch didn’t even die (but they will, and they will rise from the dead shortly thereafter, as the entire world watches). So, the Resurrection itself isn’t “The Complete Moon Survival Kit” but only the bottled air.


  3. Foxfier said

    Ah! We’re not using “Easter” in the same way.

    You’re using it as the Resurrection alone;
    I’m using it as the fulfillment.

    Neither one is wrong, just need to understand exactly what the other means.


  4. Foxfier said

    Shorter: “Resurrection Sunday” vs “Day the Sacrificed God destroyed death and restored life.”


  5. Foxfier, you might want to examine my 4 links to the CSPT dialogue I referenced. Shorter: we agree. (But on what? The links provide the answer.)


  6. Foxfier said


    *gets distracted with the ludicrous image of Perry calling someone else nasty*


  7. Heh, that’s why I provided the 4 specific links. Perry, PIATOR, Blubonnet, et al did a wondrous job of hijacking the thread. But those 4 links are, indeed, valuable. For quicker access, use links 1 and 3. 2 and 4 are backed up into 1 and 3. And then you don’t have to bother with the asininity of Perry or of PIATOR or of Blubonnet or of the other asinine asses who showed their asses on that thread (and who will get to face the Great White Throne in the future (referenced in the ABC article posted this day)).


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

%d bloggers like this: